Bestie Business Card
Catering to our locals for over 50 years, Treasure Island has become a destination restaurant. An independently owned and operated steak and seafood restaurant serving the Miami Valley and s...
Business Hours
Local Map
DirectionsAbout Moraine, Ohio, USA
MoreThe economic environment in Moraine includes manufacturing, logistics, and services, supported by major employers and its strategic location near Interstate 75. This facilitates robust transportation links to the Dayton metropolitan area for cultural and shopping experiences, including attractions like the Dayton Art Institute and Schuster Center. Community resources enrich residents' lives through quality education, healthcare access, libraries, recreational facilities, and local business support structures. Safety in Moraine aligns with national averages, bolstered by law enforcement efforts and community safety programs. The city enjoys a typical Midwestern climate with warm summers and cold winters, surrounded by scenic landscapes from its glacial past. Its affordability, combined with proximity to Dayton's amenities, makes it an attractive place for diverse populations seeking a balance of natural beauty and urban convenience.
Nominated for BestAround
Treasure Island Supper Club emerges as a compelling contender for the "BestAround" designation, distinguished by its unique fusion of American and Italian cuisine, anchored by its signature Joe's-style steak. Its location in Piqua, Ohio, within the heart of the Moraine community, positions it as a local gem catering to both casual diners and special occasion guests. The restaurant's commitment to authenticity in its culinary offerings, coupled with a full-service approach that includes gourmet pizza and Italian dishes, sets a high bar for dining quality in the region.
The positive reception from patrons is largely driven by the exceptional steak house experience, with many praising the quality, portion sizes, and overall ambiance reminiscent of classic American diners. The standout menu items, such as the cheeseburger and mozzarella sticks, have been particularly well-received, indicating a strong appeal across diverse palates. However, the occasional inconsistencies in food quality, portion sizes, and service responsiveness hint at areas needing refinement to fully capitalize on its strengths.
Despite these minor shortcomings, Treasure Island Supper Club's ability to consistently deliver memorable dining experiences, underpinned by attentive and friendly staff, solidifies its appeal. The versatile banquet facility, accommodating up to 55 guests, further enhances its versatility for various event needs. Its enduring popularity, rooted in a rich history of serving the Miami Valley, suggests that Treasure Island Supper Club is not just a restaurant but a cherished institution, poised to continue earning accolades for its unique blend of culinary excellence and hospitality.
About Treasure Island Supper Club
Treasure Island Supper Club stands out as a distinguished dining establishment nestled in the heart of Piqua, Ohio, offering a unique blend of authentic American and Italian cuisine within the Moraine community. Known for its exceptional quality, particularly its signature 3 Joe's-style steak, the club has quickly become a local favorite, especially for special occasions such as birthday parties, corporate events, and private gatherings. The establishment prides itself on providing a full-service experience, from gourmet pizza to hearty Italian dishes, all prepared with a commitment to authenticity that resonates with its clientele.
In addition to its culinary offerings, Treasure Island Supper Club is actively seeking talented individuals to join its team, emphasizing a supportive and growth-oriented work environment. The club's menu, which includes standout items like the best cheeseburger and mozzarella sticks, has garnered positive reviews from regular patrons, including a memorable seafood platter and a delightful fried armpip. This feedback underscores the establishment’s ability to consistently deliver high-quality dining experiences that cater to diverse tastes and preferences.
Beyond its culinary excellence, Treasure Island Supper Club offers a versatile banquet facility with a seating capacity of 55, making it an ideal choice for larger events. The club's commitment to creating memorable experiences extends to its customer service, exemplified by the attentive and friendly staff who ensure that every guest feels valued. For those looking to host a private event, the club invites potential guests to contact them directly via phone, email, or in-person visits, highlighting their readiness to tailor every detail to meet unique needs and preferences. With its rich history of serving the Miami Valley and surrounding areas for over five decades, Treasure Island Supper Club continues to be a beloved destination for those seeking exceptional dining and hospitality.
Category Tags
What Customers Say
1,321
Official Google Reviews
Customers have generally expressed positive experiences at Treasure Island Supper Club, highlighting the nostalgic atmosphere, quality food, and attentive service. Many reviews mention the excellent steak house experience, praising the portion sizes, pricing, and the overall dining ambiance that evokes a sense of classic American dining. However, a few reviews indicate areas for improvement, particularly concerning consistency in food quality, portion sizes, and service responsiveness. Despite these minor critiques, the overwhelming sentiment is one of satisfaction and appreciation for the establishment's unique charm and value proposition. The restaurant's ability to maintain a high standard of service and food quality, even amidst changes in ownership, has been a significant factor in its continued popularity among regulars and new visitors alike. Customers seem to view Treasure Island as a reliable destination for special occasions or a nostalgic dining experience, which contributes positively to their overall impression and willingness to return.