Mitchell’s Seafood House

Seafood Restaurant Catering Outdoor Dining

Local Map

Directions

Your browser does not support embedded maps. View larger map

About Livonia, Michigan, USA

More

Nominated for BestAround

A-
Overall Grade
Rating Scale:
A: 80-100% B: 60-79% C: 40-59% D: 20-39%

Mitchell's Seafood House emerges as a promising contender for the "BestAround" designation, distinguished by its commitment to delivering an exquisite seafood dining experience anchored in fresh, high-quality ingredients. The restaurant's menu, spanning 21 meticulously crafted courses, showcases a dedication to culinary excellence, with standout dishes like the Ora King Salmon and Butternut Squash Soup that highlight both flavor and visual appeal. This level of craftsmanship is further underscored by the flexibility in accommodating dietary preferences and special requests, ensuring a personalized dining experience.

The ambiance of Mitchell's Fish Market complements its culinary offerings, featuring outdoor seating that capitalizes on scenic views and fresh air, enhancing the overall dining atmosphere. The staff's attentiveness and dedication to quality are evident in the restaurant's recognition, including the Diners' Choice Award, which underscores its standing as a top choice in Lansing.

However, customer feedback reveals a mixed bag. While many praise the exceptional seafood quality and welcoming environment, some reviews highlight inconsistencies in food preparation, such as overcooked or under-seasoned dishes, and slower service. Additionally, a noted drawback is the limited selection of local fish options, which some diners found disappointing. Despite these minor shortcomings, the consistent positive feedback and the restaurant's loyal customer base suggest that Mitchell's Seafood House has the potential to qualify for the prestigious "BestAround" designation with targeted improvements in consistency and service.

About Mitchell’s Seafood House

Mitchell’s Fish Market, a distinguished seafood restaurant nestled in Lansing, Michigan, offers an exquisite dining experience that caters to both seafood aficionados and casual diners alike. Serving up the freshest catches of the day, the establishment prides itself on its commitment to using only the highest quality ingredients to craft dishes that are not only delicious but also visually stunning.

The restaurant's menu is a comprehensive selection of 21 courses, each meticulously designed to highlight the unique flavors and textures of its seafood offerings. From the classic Ora King Salmon with a creamy mushroom farro to the innovative Butternut Squash Soup, every dish on the menu is a testament to Mitchell’s dedication to culinary excellence.

One of the standout features of Mitchell’s Fish Market is its flexibility in accommodating special requests and dietary preferences. Whether you're looking to add protein to any salad or need a vegetarian option, the staff is always ready to assist. The menu also includes a variety of appetizers and small plates, such as the Crispy Calamari and Spicy Crispy Shrimp, which are perfect for those who want to start their meal with a bite.

The dining atmosphere at Mitchell’s Fish Market is equally impressive, with outdoor seating that takes full advantage of the fresh air and scenic views. The restaurant also offers a take-out service, making it easy for guests to enjoy their meal even when they're not dining in.

For those interested in a more formal dining experience, the General Manager, Robert Hanley, and Executive Chef Raelynn Huff, are dedicated to ensuring that every guest has an unforgettable meal. Their commitment to quality and service is evident in the restaurant’s Diners' Choice Award, which recognizes Mitchell’s Fish Market as the best seafood restaurant in Lansing.

With a wide range of menu options, convenient amenities, and a welcoming atmosphere, Mitchell’s Fish Market is a must-visit destination for anyone looking to indulge in some of the best seafood in the area. Whether you're celebrating a special occasion or simply enjoying a relaxing evening out, this restaurant offers something for every palate and every budget.

Category Tags
Seafood Restaurant Catering Outdoor Dining Group Dining

What Customers Say

4.2
Rating Based On
2,876
Official Google Reviews
5
1612
4
653
3
288
2
173
1
150

Customer experiences for Mitchell's Seafood House varied notably, reflecting a mix of high praise and areas for improvement. Positive feedback highlighted exceptional seafood quality, particularly praising dishes like the lobster bisque, fillet mignon, and shrimp scampi noodles.

Many customers appreciated the warm, welcoming atmosphere, attentive service, and the restaurant's commitment to freshness, especially noted in the oysters and ceasars salad. A few reviews mentioned standout experiences, such as a birthday celebration at Mitchell's where the service was outstanding and the ambiance memorable.

However, some reviews pointed out issues like inconsistent food quality, particularly with overcooked or under-seasoned dishes, and complaints about service being slow or unhelpful. One customer noted the lack of local fish options, which detracted from the overall experience. Despite these criticisms, several customers expressed a willingness to return, suggesting that while there's room for improvement, Mitchell's Seafood House maintains a loyal customer base and offers a dining experience that many find enjoyable and memorable.