Noodles and Company

Restaurant Food Service Dining Establishment

Bestie Business Card

Visit your nearby Noodles & Company at 1416 W McGalliard Rd in Muncie, IN to discover the world's favorite noodle dishes, pasta, salads and soups. Order online ahead of time for pickup.

Social Links

Local Map

Directions

Your browser does not support embedded maps. View larger map

About Muncie, Indiana, USA

More

Nominated for BestAround

A-
Overall Grade
Rating Scale:
A: 80-100% B: 60-79% C: 40-59% D: 20-39%

Noodles and Company in Muncie, Indiana, presents a compelling case for consideration in the "BestAround" designation, primarily due to its innovative and diverse menu that successfully blends international and American flavors, appealing to a broad spectrum of diners. The restaurant's unique features, such as the three-story indoor maze and the Noodles Rewards program, enhance the dining experience, offering both convenience and a touch of whimsy. The culinary excellence is evident in dishes like the Elbow noodles with cheddar cheese sauce and the Cavatappi noodles in pesto, each showcasing fresh, high-quality ingredients and balanced flavors.

However, the restaurant's nomination for "BestAround" is tempered by significant concerns regarding hygiene and consistency. Reports of unsanitary conditions, including issues with hair in food and inadequate sanitization, have marred the dining experience for some patrons. These problems, coupled with inconsistencies in food quality-such as dry noodles and undercooked meats-have led to mixed reviews, with several customers expressing disappointment and even reconsidering their visits due to hygiene violations.

Despite these challenges, Noodles and Company's strengths in atmosphere, cleanliness, and value for money remain notable. The welcoming environment and the restaurant's commitment to customer satisfaction through its rewards program are commendable. For those seeking a memorable dining experience that balances quality and affordability, Noodles and Company offers a solid foundation, though it must address its hygiene and consistency issues to fully qualify for the prestigious "BestAround" designation.

About Noodles and Company

Noodles and Company, a vibrant dining destination located in Muncie, Indiana, offers a diverse menu that caters to a wide array of culinary preferences. The restaurant features three-story indoor attractions, including a unique maze, which adds an interactive element to the dining experience. For those seeking convenience, Noodles Rewards members can enjoy a $0 delivery fee through October 21st, making it easy to savor the restaurant's offerings from the comfort of home.

The menu at Noodles and Company is a testament to culinary creativity, featuring a blend of international and American flavors. Standout dishes include the Elbow noodles in creamy cheddar & jack cheese sauce with seared steak, the Cavatappi noodles in basil pesto, and the Fettuccine noodles in garlic butter sauce with sautéed shrimp. Each dish is crafted with fresh ingredients and a focus on balance, from the rich, savory flavors of the rigatoni in balsamic vinaigrette to the light, crispy textures of the wavy egg noodles.

Noodles and Company also prides itself on its commitment to sustainability and community engagement. The restaurant's signature soup, made daily with chicken breast, celery, carrots, onion, and wavy egg noodles, is a hearty and flavorful option that showcases the restaurant's dedication to quality and freshness. For those looking to try something new, the restaurant introduces regular specials like the Crispy Chicken Bacon Alfredo, Lemon Garlic Shrimp Scampi, and Chipotle Chicken Cavatappi, which highlight its innovative approach to classic dishes.

In addition to its extensive menu, Noodles and Company offers a welcoming atmosphere with both indoor and outdoor seating options. The restaurant's commitment to customer satisfaction is further emphasized through its Noodles Rewards program, which not only provides points for every order but also exclusive freebies and discounts. Whether you're dining for a special occasion or a casual meal, Noodles and Company delivers a memorable experience that combines delicious food, unique ambiance, and a commitment to quality.

Category Tags
Restaurant Food Service Dining Establishment Eatery

What Customers Say

4.3
Rating Based On
668
Official Google Reviews
5
374
4
178
3
64
2
23
1
29

Customers have reported a range of experiences at Noodles and Company, from highly positive to deeply disappointing. Many praised the quality of the food, particularly the noodles, steaks, and seafood dishes, noting flavors that were well-executed and portions generous. The service was generally described as friendly, attentive, and efficient, with some staff members going above and beyond in accommodating special requests or providing helpful recommendations.

However, there were also significant criticisms. Several reviews highlighted issues with cleanliness, including reports of hair in food, lack of proper sanitization, and general unsanitary conditions. One reviewer specifically mentioned a severe hygiene violation that made them reconsider returning. Another noted inconsistencies in food quality, such as dry noodles and undercooked meats, which detracted from the dining experience.

Some customers expressed frustration over service issues, including long wait times, incorrect orders, and staff not taking adequate steps to rectify problems after complaints were raised. The lack of transparency in addressing these issues, such as delayed responses to complaints about gift card refunds, further exacerbated negative experiences.

Despite the mixed reviews, there are also several positive comments about the restaurant's atmosphere, cleanliness, and value for money. Many customers appreciated the variety of menu options, especially the vegetarian choices, and the welcoming environment, particularly during busy periods. The staff's friendliness and willingness to go the extra mile for guests were frequently mentioned as standout features.

Overall, while Noodles and Company has areas for improvement, particularly in hygiene and consistency, it continues to receive praise for its food quality and service, making it a place worth considering for regular visits, especially for those looking for good value and a decent dining experience.