Bestie Business Card
3001 El Camino Real, Atherton, CA 650.546.7700 info@selbysrestaurant.
Business Hours
Local Map
DirectionsAbout Redwood City, California, USA
MoreThe city boasts an attractive downtown area rich with Victorian-era buildings, complemented by modern developments like new high-rise towers, illustrating its evolving skyline. Points of interest include the historic Fox Theatre and vibrant parks like Caltrain Park and Edgewood Natural Preserve. With a strong arts scene and diverse culinary options, Redwood City supports a lively community spirit enhanced by 255 sunny days yearly. The economic landscape is robust with tech, professional services, and healthcare industries dominating. Transportation is streamlined through Caltrain service and access to Highway 101, while the city's commitment to safety and climate resilience ensures a secure and sustainable environment for its residents. Local amenities cater to various tastes, offering everything from cultural events to outdoor recreation, reinforcing Redwood City’s unique charm as a blend of historic appeal and forward-thinking innovation.
Nominated for BestAround
Selby's positions itself as a standout dining destination in Atherton, California, lauded for its commitment to local sourcing and community engagement. The restaurant's flagship The Grill House successfully marries a refined bar experience with sophisticated fine dining, attracting a discerning clientele seeking authenticity and quality. This is evident in the consistent praise for its service, particularly the attentive staff who go above and beyond, and the ambiance that seamlessly blends classic elegance with modern touches.
However, Selby's faces its share of criticisms. While the food receives mixed reviews, with some diners experiencing overcooked dishes or limited vegetarian options, the restaurant's focus on local, high-quality ingredients remains a strength. The pricing, while appreciated for its value, occasionally feels inflexible for lighter meals or those seeking more variety. This inconsistency in execution and occasional service hiccups pose challenges to consistently delivering the "exceptional" experience Selby's aims for.
Despite these hurdles, Selby's undeniably cultivates memorable experiences, particularly for special occasions. Its ability to create a sophisticated yet welcoming atmosphere makes it a prime choice for those seeking an upscale dining experience. To solidify its "BestAround" nomination, Selby's must address recurring issues like food consistency and pricing transparency while ensuring its ambiance remains consistently enchanting for all guests. The key lies in balancing its commitment to quality with the flexibility needed to cater to a diverse clientele.
About Selby's
Selby's, nestled at 3001 El Camino Real in Atherton, California, stands out as a premier dining destination within Redwood City, celebrated for its commitment to local sourcing and community engagement. The restaurant's flagship establishment, The Grill House, offers a refined yet approachable atmosphere that seamlessly blends the charm of a traditional bar with the sophistication of a fine dining venue. This unique setting is complemented by a dynamic sports bar that features an extensive selection of locally brewed craft beers, artisanal wines, and expertly crafted cocktails, making it a go-to spot for both casual patrons and dedicated beer enthusiasts.
Operating seven nights a week, Selby's ensures a consistent flow of customers, with reservations and walk-ins both welcomed to enjoy the full menu and ambiance. The restaurant's dedication to local sourcing is evident in its menu offerings, which highlight the best of California's agricultural and artisanal producers, from fresh seafood to locally grown produce. This focus not only supports the local economy but also enhances the dining experience by providing guests with authentic, high-quality ingredients.
Strategically located in Redwood City, Selby's benefits from its prime position in a vibrant community that values quality and authenticity. The restaurant's commitment to excellence and its welcoming atmosphere have solidified its reputation as one of the standout establishments in the area, attracting a loyal customer base and contributing positively to the local culinary scene.
Category Tags
What Customers Say
434
Official Google Reviews
Customer experiences at Selby's range widely from highly positive to notably disappointing, but several themes emerge consistently. Positive feedback often centers around the exceptional service, particularly noting the attentiveness and personalized attention, especially from staff like Chris who went above and beyond to resolve a mistake. The ambiance is frequently praised for its sophisticated yet inviting nature, with some customers appreciating the unique blend of classic elegance and modern decor that suits fine dining occasions well.
Disappointments commonly arise from the food quality, with several reviews mentioning issues such as overcooked or under-seasoned dishes, a lack of variety in vegetarian options, and unexpected charges for amenities like bottled water. The pricing is another frequent point of contention; while many appreciate the value given the high-quality ingredients and service, others feel the prix fixe menu may not cater adequately to lighter dining preferences or those seeking more flexibility in their meal choices.
The restaurant excels in creating memorable experiences, particularly for special occasions like anniversaries and birthdays, where the combination of food, service, and ambiance is seamlessly executed. However, consistency remains a challenge, with some diners noting variability in the execution of dishes and occasional mistakes in service or menu presentation.
Overall, Selby's stands out as a top choice for those seeking an upscale dining experience with a focus on quality service and a refined atmosphere. The restaurant's reputation for excellence is evident, but the key to maintaining its high standards lies in addressing recurring issues such as food consistency, pricing transparency, and ensuring that the ambiance remains consistently enjoyable for all guests.