Bestie Business Card
Founded by Michael Chernow and Jay Wainwright on Broome and Mulberry, Seamore's brings Montauk to your sidewalk - serving sustainable fish tacos, lobster rolls, local oysters, and casual beach vibes.
Local Map
DirectionsAbout New York, New York, USA
MoreThe city’s infrastructure supports extensive connectivity through an efficient public transportation system comprising subways, buses, and commuter rails, alongside major airports linking it globally. Community resources are abundant, including a comprehensive network of schools, libraries, healthcare facilities, and higher education institutions like prestigious universities. Despite crime rates being higher than the national average, they have significantly decreased since the 1980s. New York City experiences four distinct seasons with hot summers and cold winters. Its cultural vibrancy is further highlighted by its thriving arts scene, renowned fashion industry, and dynamic culinary offerings ranging from high-end dining to street food, making it a truly unique urban experience.
Nominated for BestAround
Seamore's Brookfield Place emerges as a compelling contender for the "BestAround" accolade, distinguished by its unique culinary offerings and vibrant atmosphere. The restaurant's dedication to sustainable seafood and local sourcing sets it apart, appealing to environmentally conscious diners and food enthusiasts alike. Its menu, ranging from classic fish tacos to sophisticated dishes like the Founder's All Day IPA and Seamore's White Sangria, showcases a creative and diverse approach to seafood cuisine, with standout highlights such as the Guacamole + Chips and Seamore's Trio. The ambiance, blending casual and elegant elements, further enhances its appeal as a social hub, particularly popular for happy hours and private events.
However, the restaurant's journey to "BestAround" status is not without its challenges. While many patrons laud the exceptional quality of the food, especially the seafood, others have noted inconsistencies in service, cold dishes, and overcooked items. These criticisms suggest areas where refinement is needed, particularly in maintaining consistent food preparation and service standards. Despite these issues, the warm and accommodating staff remain a significant draw, contributing to a welcoming dining experience.
In conclusion, Seamore's Brookfield Place balances its strengths in sustainable practices and unique menu offerings with areas for improvement in consistency and service. For those seeking a memorable seafood dining experience that combines quality food with a cozy, inviting atmosphere, the restaurant offers a compelling proposition, albeit one that may not meet every expectation. It stands as a noteworthy contender in the competitive dining scene, deserving of recognition for its efforts while acknowledging the path to further excellence.
About Seamore's Brookfield Place
Seamore's Brookfield Place is a vibrant and bustling seafood restaurant located at 250 Vesey Street, Montauk, New York, NY 10281. This flagship location offers a unique blend of casual and elegant dining experiences, perfect for both casual gatherings and special occasions. The restaurant prides itself on its commitment to sustainable and local seafood, featuring a diverse menu that includes everything from classic fish tacos and shrimp skewers to more sophisticated dishes like the Founder's All Day IPA and Seamore's White Sangria.
The menu showcases a wide array of flavors and textures, with options ranging from light and refreshing cocktails to hearty mains. Highlights include the Guacamole + Chips, Firecracker Cauliflower, and Seamore's Trio, each offering a unique twist on traditional seafood favorites. The restaurant's commitment to sustainability is evident in its selection of local and sustainable seafood, ensuring that diners can enjoy delicious meals while supporting environmentally responsible practices.
Seamore's Brookfield Place is not only a culinary destination but also a social hub, particularly popular for its happy hour and private event bookings. The restaurant's beachy and nautical ambiance, combined with its modern and airy decor, creates an inviting atmosphere that appeals to a wide range of customers. Whether you're celebrating a birthday, hosting a corporate event, or simply enjoying a romantic dinner, Seamore's Brookfield Place offers an unforgettable experience. For reservations, especially during peak times, it is recommended to contact the restaurant directly through Resy or OpenTable. The restaurant's proximity to Montauk's scenic beauty and its well-maintained patio make it an ideal choice for those looking to enjoy the coastal vibe while savoring exceptional cuisine.
Category Tags
What Customers Say
396
Official Google Reviews
Customer experiences at Seamore's Brookfield Place showcase a wide range of opinions, reflecting both high praise and areas for improvement. Some patrons have consistently highlighted the restaurant's exceptional food quality, particularly their seafood offerings, with many describing dishes as "absolutely delicious," "incredible," and "highly recommended." The ambiance, often noted for its cozy and inviting atmosphere, has been a positive point for several reviews, though some have mentioned it being a bit small or lacking in certain features like outdoor seating with scenic views.
However, not all experiences have been uniformly positive. A few reviews pointed out issues such as cold or overcooked dishes, poor portion sizes, and service inconsistencies. For instance, one customer had an experience where the fried cauliflower arrived ice cold, and another had a lobster roll that was overcooked despite being on the pricier side. These negative experiences highlight areas where the restaurant might need to improve its food preparation and consistency.
Despite these criticisms, Seamore's continues to receive commendations for its friendly and accommodating staff, which seems to be a significant draw for many customers. The happy hour offerings have also been well-received, with several reviews mentioning the great selection of drinks and the welcoming service during those times. The restaurant's commitment to using fresh, locally sourced ingredients and its efforts to create a unique, hipster atmosphere are also noted positively.
Overall, Seamore's Brookfield Place appears to be a restaurant that balances quality food with a somewhat inconsistent service experience. Customers who visit are likely to appreciate the restaurant's strengths while being mindful of the occasional shortcomings, making it a place worth trying but perhaps not expecting perfection in every aspect.