Bestie Business Card
Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Mt. Dew, Orange Crush, Sierra Mist, Root Beer, Dr. Pepper, Lemonade - $3.
Business Hours
Local Map
DirectionsAbout Newark, Ohio, USA
MoreNewark's attractions are varied, appealing to different interests. The Licking River offers outdoor activities such as fishing and kayaking, while downtown experiences revitalization with new businesses and dining options. Cultural enrichment comes from the Granville Arts Center’s events, complemented by local festivals celebrating agricultural heritage. Community resources include a strong public school system, libraries, healthcare facilities, and ample recreational spaces. Transportation is convenient, with major highways like Interstate 70 connecting the city to broader areas, though public transit within Newark remains limited. With a climate featuring distinct seasons and generally favorable safety ratings, Newark combines its historical charm with modern development, creating a welcoming lifestyle for families and individuals alike.
Nominated for BestAround
Don & Sue's Pizza, a cornerstone of Licking County since 1972, has earned a "BestAround" nomination through its unwavering commitment to classic pizza excellence and a consistently welcoming atmosphere. The restaurant's signature thin, golden-brown crust and time-honored menu, featuring both traditional and unique toppings, speak volumes about its dedication to quality. This consistency in taste and presentation is a key factor in its enduring popularity.
The value proposition at Don & Sue's strikes a fine balance, offering affordable options alongside premium dishes that cater to diverse palates. The extensive menu, coupled with a wide selection of beverages and customizable sides, ensures there's something for everyone, solidifying its appeal beyond just pizza enthusiasts. The recent expansion to Newark, Ohio, with upgraded amenities like private rooms and a pickup window, demonstrates a strategic move to broaden its reach while retaining its core customer base.
However, while customer reviews predominantly praise the quality of food, service, and ambiance, some concerns regarding delivery times and occasional inconsistencies in specific menu items, like overpriced or poorly prepared wings, suggest areas for improvement. Despite these minor shortcomings, Don & Sue's Pizza's strong foundation, commitment to its core values, and evolving appeal make it a compelling contender for the "BestAround" designation. Its ability to blend tradition with modern convenience positions it well for continued success in the competitive dining landscape.
About Don & Sue's Pizza
Don & Sue's Pizza, a beloved institution in Licking County since 1972, continues to deliver on its promise of consistent excellence with its signature thin, golden-brown crispy cracker crust and a menu that has remained unchanged for decades. The restaurant's commitment to quality is evident in its carefully selected beverages, which include a variety of sodas, teas, and house-made dressings, catering to diverse tastes and preferences.
The pricing structure at Don & Sue's reflects a balance between affordability and quality, with options ranging from budget-friendly single-topping pizzas starting at $3.00 to premium dishes like the Buffalo Chicken and Meatball specials, priced at $11.00 or more. The restaurant offers a wide array of toppings, from classic favorites like pepperoni and sausage to more unique additions such as pineapple and anchovies, allowing customers to customize their meals to perfection.
In addition to its robust menu, Don & Sue's has expanded its offerings to include a variety of sides and appetizers, ensuring that diners have plenty of options between meals. The new location in Newark, Ohio, opened in August 2021, bringing the brand to a broader audience with amenities like additional parking, private rooms for events, and a pickup window for convenience. The restaurant's online ordering system is set to launch in fall/winter 2021, further enhancing its accessibility and appeal to a wider customer base.
Whether you're a long-time regular or new to the area, Don & Sue's Pizza remains a top choice for fresh, homemade pizza and a welcoming atmosphere that has made it a staple in the community for nearly five decades. Book your visit today and experience the enduring charm of Don & Sue's.
Category Tags
What Customers Say
772
Official Google Reviews
Customers at Don & Sue's Pizza have consistently highlighted the quality and ambiance of their dining experience, with many praising the excellent pizza offerings, particularly noting the variety and taste of items like the carnivore pizza and pot roast subs. Several reviews mention the friendly and attentive service, which has contributed significantly to the positive feedback. The decor, often described as welcoming and unique, adds to the overall appeal, making the restaurant a favorite for both casual diners and those looking for a more relaxed atmosphere.
However, there are also instances where customers have raised concerns, particularly regarding delivery times and issues with specific menu items. Some have noted delays in delivery, which can be frustrating, especially when expecting a quick service. Additionally, there have been complaints about the quality of certain items, such as wings that were overpriced and poorly fried, or pizzas that lacked toppings or had unexpected ingredients. These negative experiences highlight areas where the restaurant could improve, such as streamlining delivery processes and ensuring consistency in food quality.
Despite these minor criticisms, the overall sentiment from customer reviews is predominantly positive. Many reviewers appreciate the cleanliness of the restaurant, the variety of beverages available, and the welcoming atmosphere. The restaurant's ability to accommodate special requests, like party rooms, and its commitment to providing a good value for money further enhance its reputation. For potential customers, Don & Sue's Pizza remains a strong contender in the local dining scene, offering a unique blend of comfort food and a pleasant dining environment that many find hard to resist.