The Italian Pie Shoppe

Pizza Restaurant Pizza Italian Food

Bestie Business Card

Road construction has started in front of our St. Paul location on Grand Avenue, so our hours have changed slightly. We will now be open Sunday-Thursday, 11am to 8pm.

Social Links

Local Map

Directions

Your browser does not support embedded maps. View larger map

About St Paul, Minnesota, USA

More

Nominated for BestAround

A-
Overall Grade
Rating Scale:
A: 80-100% B: 60-79% C: 40-59% D: 20-39%

The Italian Pie Shoppe presents itself as a compelling contender for "BestAround" recognition, particularly through its adaptability and commitment to customer convenience. The recent extension of its hours, now spanning from 11am to 8pm on Sundays through Thursday and 11am to 9pm on Fridays and Saturdays, speaks volumes about its responsiveness to local needs and its dedication to accessibility. This flexibility caters to a broad spectrum of diners, from those seeking a quick bite to families with children or those simply looking for a change of pace from traditional dining hours.

The restaurant's strategic embrace of online ordering and delivery further solidifies its standing as a forward-thinking establishment. By offering these services, The Italian Pie Shoppe not only expands its reach beyond the physical limitations of its three locations but also caters to a modern palate seeking convenience without compromising on quality. This blend of tradition and innovation is a key factor that could lead to its nomination for "BestAround."

However, while the restaurant's offerings are lauded, particularly the authentic deep dish pizza, there are areas for improvement. The cheese-stuffed pizza has received mixed reviews, with some diners finding it overly dense and requiring utensils, highlighting a potential area where refinement could elevate the overall dining experience. Despite these minor shortcomings, the consistent praise for the core offerings, coupled with its loyal customer base and favorable comparisons to established brands, positions The Italian Pie Shoppe as a strong candidate for the "BestAround" accolade. Its ability to balance tradition with modern convenience makes it a noteworthy example of a local institution thriving in a competitive landscape.

About The Italian Pie Shoppe

The Italian Pie Shoppe, a beloved local institution, has adapted to the evolving landscape of dining by adjusting its operational hours following recent road construction near its St. Paul location on Grand Avenue. This change has resulted in a more flexible schedule, extending its Sunday-Thursday hours to 11am to 8pm and Friday and Saturday from 11am to 9pm. These adjustments reflect a strategic move to cater to the changing needs of its customer base, particularly those who value convenience and flexibility in their dining experiences.

In addition to its modified hours, The Italian Pie Shoppe has expanded its service offerings to include online ordering and delivery, enhancing accessibility for patrons who may not be able to visit the restaurant in person. Customers can explore current specials through the provided link, ensuring they can enjoy the authentic flavors of Italian pies from the comfort of their homes or vehicles. The delivery service, available in Downtown St. Paul, further broadens the shop's reach, allowing it to serve a wider audience and maintain its commitment to community engagement.

The Italian Pie Shoppe operates three key locations across the Minneapolis/St. Paul area, each designed to optimize customer convenience and satisfaction. These locations offer distinct dining experiences: dine-in, carry-out, and delivery options, catering to diverse preferences and lifestyles. The dine-in service remains open from 11am to 8pm on Sundays through Thursdays, providing a welcoming atmosphere for those who prefer to enjoy their meals in person. Carry-out is available from 11am to 9pm on Fridays and Saturdays, offering a quick and easy solution for busy patrons. Delivery hours are more flexible, ranging from 4pm to 10pm on Mondays through Thursdays, and from noon to 9pm on Fridays and Saturdays, ensuring that customers can enjoy their favorite pies from the comfort of their homes or offices.

Category Tags
Pizza Restaurant Pizza Italian Food Dining Local Restaurant

What Customers Say

4.2
Rating Based On
437
Official Google Reviews
5
284
4
63
3
26
2
21
1
43

Customers of The Italian Pie Shoppe have shared a range of experiences, highlighting both standout qualities and areas for improvement. Many praise the deep dish pizza as a highlight, noting its buttery crust, balanced sauce, and overall deliciousness. Customers appreciate the authentic Chicago-style flavors, the calming atmosphere, and the attentive service, often mentioning the quality of the toppings and the consistency of their visits over years.

However, some reviews also point out areas where the restaurant could enhance its offerings. Several customers have noted disappointment with the cheese-stuffed pizza, describing it as dense and requiring forks due to its heaviness. Others have criticized the service, with comments about being rushed or unprofessional, particularly when ordering from the front.

Despite these mixed reviews, many customers express a strong loyalty to the restaurant, recommending it repeatedly and suggesting it as a must-visit spot in Saint Paul. Some even compare it favorably to more well-known pizza chains, indicating a high level of satisfaction with the core offerings. The consistent praise for the deep dish pizza suggests that while there may be room for refinement in other areas, the restaurant has successfully established itself as a go-to destination for authentic Italian-style deep dish pizza.