Bestie Business Card
Since 1972, Toby's Original Little Italy Pizza in New York offers top-notch New York-style pizzas and subs, including dine-in and take-out options.
Business Hours
Local Map
DirectionsAbout St Petersburg, Florida, USA
MoreThe city's appeal lies in its vibrant cultural scene and varied attractions, including the Salvador Dalí Museum, St. Petersburg Pier, and Fort De Soto Park. A dynamic downtown offers art galleries, theaters, and live music venues, with events like the Grand Prix of St. Petersburg adding to its allure. Economically, it is diversifying with growth in technology, healthcare, and finance sectors, supported by employers like BayCare Health System and Raymond James Financial. Transportation includes Tampa International Airport and major highways such as Interstate 275. The city's community resources encompass quality education, health services, and recreational facilities. Safety measures align with national averages, though property crime varies across areas. St. Petersburg enjoys a subtropical climate with warm summers and mild winters, complemented by stunning Gulf Coast sunsets and diverse natural environments. Its blend of artistic flair, progressive spirit, and commitment to sustainability sets it apart as an exceptional place for living, working, and enjoying its coastal lifestyle.
Nominated for BestAround
Toby's Original Little Italy Pizza emerges as a compelling contender for "BestAround" recognition, distinguished by its unwavering commitment to authenticity and quality in its Italian-inspired pizza offerings. The restaurant's dedication to traditional Neapolitan cooking, coupled with Southern twists, resonates deeply with patrons seeking an experience that feels both familiar and comforting. This is further enhanced by the use of high-quality, locally-sourced ingredients, ensuring each bite delivers a taste of Italy that is both genuine and inviting.
Operationally, Toby's Original Little Italy Pizza demonstrates a keen understanding of its clientele's needs. While weekday service remains efficient with a standard preparation time, the restaurant proactively adjusts for weekend surges, prioritizing orders and streamlining service to maintain quality even during peak hours. This adaptability, combined with well-trained staff who balance speed with attentiveness, underscores their ability to deliver consistent satisfaction across varying demand levels.
The restaurant's prime location in Clearwater, coupled with a welcoming ambiance, positions it as a sought-after destination for both locals and tourists. While minor inconsistencies occasionally surface, the overall reception remains overwhelmingly positive. The pizza's enduring appeal, coupled with its value proposition, solidifies Toby's Original Little Italy Pizza's potential to earn accolades like "BestAround," cementing its place as a cherished local institution. This blend of authenticity, operational efficiency, and community connection paints a compelling case for its recognition.
About Tobys Original Little Italy Pizza
Toby's Original Little Italy Pizza is a beloved local eatery nestled in the heart of Clearwater, Florida, known for its authentic Italian flavors and cozy atmosphere. The restaurant specializes in traditional Little Italian pizza, offering a menu that captures the essence of classic Neapolitan cooking with a touch of Southern flair. From the crispy, cheesy crusts to the rich, savory sauces, each slice is crafted with care to ensure a dining experience that resonates with both locals and visitors alike. The establishment prides itself on its commitment to using high-quality ingredients, sourced whenever possible, to deliver a taste of Italy that feels both familiar and inviting.
For customers dining during the week, particularly from Sunday through Thursday, Toby's Original Little Italy Pizza offers a standard preparation time of 20 minutes per order. This efficient service ensures that patrons can enjoy their meals promptly without compromising on quality. However, the restaurant anticipates higher demand on Fridays and Saturdays, especially during peak hours, and has adjusted its operational schedule to accommodate this increased traffic. To manage these fluctuations, the staff is well-trained to expedite service without sacrificing attention to detail, ensuring that each customer receives the same level of care and satisfaction they expect from a family-owned establishment.
The restaurant's location in Clearwater provides a convenient spot for both residents and tourists seeking an authentic Italian dining experience. While the 20-minute preparation time is standard for weekday orders, Toby's Original Little Italy Pizza recognizes the potential for longer wait times on weekends, particularly on Friday and Saturday nights. To address this, the restaurant has implemented a system to prioritize weekend orders, allowing customers to enjoy their meals within an additional 10 minutes of the standard 20-minute estimate. This flexible approach not only enhances customer satisfaction but also helps manage the increased volume of traffic that characterizes these evenings.
Category Tags
What Customers Say
4,258
Official Google Reviews
Customers consistently praise Toby's Original Little Italy Pizza for its authentic New York style pizza, highlighting its cheesy crusts, crispy edges, and robust sauces. Many appreciate the generous portions and the variety of classic pizzas, from cheeses to meat-lovers, finding them satisfying and well-executed.
Some reviews mention the strong community feel, with friendly staff and a welcoming atmosphere that makes patrons feel at home. Others note the consistency of quality over time, calling it a "must-see" spot in Tampa Bay despite occasional inconsistencies in crust texture or sauce richness.
While some reviewers express disappointment with specific items like burnt crusts or undercooked pizzas, the overall sentiment leans positive, emphasizing the pizza's deliciousness, value for money, and the restaurant's enduring appeal as a beloved local institution.