Select Insurance Group

Insurance Agency Auto Insurance Home Insurance

Bestie Business Card

Get free insurance quotes in Florida, North Carolina, and South Carolina. Call now!

Business Hours

Mon: 9:00am - 5:30pm
Tue: 9:00am - 5:30pm
Wed: 9:00am - 5:30pm
Thu: 9:00am - 5:30pm
Fri: 9:00am - 5:30pm
Sat: Closed
Sun: Closed

Local Map

Directions

Your browser does not support embedded maps. View larger map

About Orlando, Florida, USA

More

Nominated for BestAround

A-
Overall Grade
Rating Scale:
A: 80-100% B: 60-79% C: 40-59% D: 20-39%

Select Insurance Group emerges as a formidable player in the insurance agency sector, particularly noted for its expansive regional reach across Florida, North Carolina, South Carolina, Virginia, and Georgia. Founded with a vision spanning over two decades, the agency has carved out a niche through a strategic blend of technological innovation and customer-centric service. Its comprehensive product offerings-spanning auto, home, commercial, motorcycle, and specialized insurance-are underpinned by a commitment to affordability without sacrificing quality. This is achieved through advanced technology that facilitates instant rate comparisons from over 40 top-tier carriers, ensuring clients receive the best coverage at competitive prices.

The agency's reputation for personalized service, bolstered by bilingual quote hotlines and an extensive office directory, further distinguishes it in a crowded market. Customers frequently commend the agency's agents, such as Adriana Alonso, Karola Barreto, and Diana Estrada, for their exceptional customer service, which includes patient assistance, clear product explanations, and proactive issue resolution. These elements have fostered high levels of customer satisfaction and loyalty, positioning Select Insurance Group as a reliable choice for those seeking comprehensive insurance solutions.

However, the mixed reviews reveal significant areas for improvement.

Negative feedback highlights persistent issues with customer service, including instances of rudeness, long wait times, and inadequate claim handling. The lack of transparency and communication in critical situations like denied claims and policy cancellations has eroded trust among some clients.

For Select Insurance Group to fully realize its potential and secure the prestigious BestAround nomination, it must address these shortcomings by enhancing customer service training, improving response times, and ensuring consistent, professional interactions across all customer touchpoints. Only then can it solidify its standing as a leading insurance agency.

About Select Insurance Group

Select Insurance Group stands out as a premier insurance agency with a robust presence across Florida, North Carolina, South Carolina, Virginia, and Georgia. Founded over two decades ago in the vibrant metropolitan areas of Orlando and Tampa, the company has built a reputation for delivering exceptional insuranceservices through a blend of expertise, technology, and customer-centric approaches. With over three decades of experience in the insurance industry, Select Insurance Group offers a comprehensive suite of products including auto, home, commercial, motorcycle, and specialized insurance solutions, all aimed at providing financial protection and peace of mind to its clients.

What sets Select Insurance Group apart is its commitment to affordability without compromising on quality. The agency prides itself on offering competitive rates through advanced technology that provides instant, competitive rate comparisons from over 40 top-tier insurance carriers. This technological edge ensures that customers receive the best possible coverage at prices that fit their budgets. Additionally, Select Insurance Group emphasizes personalized service, with bilingual quote hotlines and an extensive office directory ensuring that clients can access expert assistance whenever needed.

Select Insurance Group's dedication to customer service is evident in its flexible and accessible contact options. Whether through traditional phone calls, text messages, or automated systems, the agency ensures that clients can easily reach out for quotes, account management, or product inquiries. The company’s commitment to security is also noteworthy, as it employs state-of-the-art online safeguards to protect personal information. By combining these elements—affordable rates, comprehensive coverage, advanced technology, and exceptional service—the agency has established itself as a trusted ally for individuals and businesses seeking reliable insurance solutions in the Carolinas and beyond.

Category Tags
Insurance Agency Auto Insurance Home Insurance Commercial Insurance

What Customers Say

4.6
Rating Based On
240
Official Google Reviews
5
211
4
7
3
1
2
2
1
19

Customers have shared a wide range of experiences with Select Insurance Group, reflecting both highly positive and significantly negative interactions. On the positive side, many customers highlight exceptional customer service, particularly from agents like Adriana Alonso, Karola Barreto, and Diana Estrada, who are praised for their patience, professionalism, and willingness to go above and beyond to resolve issues. These agents are often credited with helping customers find the best rates, explaining complex insurance products clearly, and providing timely assistance, which has led to high satisfaction levels and numerous recommendations.

However, the negative experiences are equally notable and underscore areas where the company could improve significantly. Customers have reported poor customer service, including rude and aggressive agents, long wait times, and a lack of responsiveness. Issues such as denied claims without proper explanation, cancellation of policies without clear communication, and even threats of account suspension have been documented. These negative experiences have led to customers feeling frustrated and even considering switching to competitors, highlighting the need for more robust customer service training and oversight.

The mixed reviews also suggest that while Select Insurance Group has the potential to be a top-tier agency, it requires consistent effort to address and rectify the issues that have arisen. Customers who have had particularly bad experiences emphasize the importance of transparency, clear communication, and a commitment to customer satisfaction. For the company to maintain its positive reputation and continue to attract new business, it must prioritize these areas and implement systemic changes to ensure that all customer interactions are handled with professionalism and care.