Bestie Business Card
Over the decades, the hardware store remained in continuous operation changing ownership just four times.
Business Hours
Local Map
DirectionsAbout Auburn, Indiana, USA
MoreAuburn’s community resources include a comprehensive library system, quality educational institutions, Parkview Hospital for healthcare, and varied recreational facilities. Transportation within the city is convenient, thanks to major highways like U.S. Route 6 and Indiana State Road 9, with Fort Wayne International Airport providing broader access. The city enjoys lower crime rates than national averages due to effective policing strategies, enhancing its reputation as a safe community. With a humid continental climate featuring warm summers and cold winters, Auburn offers an engaging lifestyle, complete with restaurants, shopping centers, golf courses, and cultural events, making it attractive for families, professionals, and retirees alike.
Nominated for BestAround
Auburn City Steakhouse, with its storied history dating back to 1859, stands out as a prime candidate for the "BestAround" designation, particularly in the competitive dining scene of Auburn, Indiana. The restaurant's evolution from a hardware store to a revered steakhouse under the stewardship of the James Family exemplifies a successful blend of heritage preservation and modern culinary innovation. The meticulous renovation, which retained original architectural elements like the freight elevator and hardwood floors, not only honors its past but also creates a unique ambiance that distinguishes it from newer establishments.
The dining experience at Auburn City Steakhouse is marked by exceptional quality, with customers consistently praising the steaks for their tenderness and flavor, especially the prime rib and ribeye. The commitment to using fresh, high-quality ingredients is a standout feature, enhancing the restaurant's reputation for superior taste. Service is another key strength, characterized by friendly, knowledgeable staff who go above and beyond to meet customer needs, from accommodating special dietary requests to providing personalized recommendations.
While minor issues like occasional wait times and occasional burnt dishes are noted, these do not overshadow the overall positive reception. The ambiance, a harmonious blend of historic charm and contemporary design, significantly contributes to the dining experience, making it both inviting and memorable. Pricing is viewed favorably by customers who find the quality of food and service to warrant the higher costs. The availability of special menus and unique offerings further elevates the restaurant's appeal, solidifying its position as a top choice for those seeking an exceptional dining experience in Auburn.
About Auburn City Steakhouse
Auburn City Steakhouse, a historic dining establishment with roots tracing back to 1859, has evolved from its humble beginnings as a hardware store into a prominent steakhouse in the heart of Auburn, Indiana. The original family, Joseph Davis, laid the foundation for what would become a beloved local institution. Over the decades, the business has seen several hands of ownership, each contributing to its legacy while maintaining a commitment to preserving the past. In 2016, the James Family, with their visionary leadership, acquired the hardware store and transformed it into a steakhouse that not only serves exquisite American cuisine but also pays homage to its rich history.
The renovation process was meticulous, with a particular focus on retaining the original architectural elements that define the establishment. From the freight elevator and NCR cash register to the original hardwood floors and leaded glass windows, the steakhouse has become a living museum of Auburn's culinary heritage. Bob Lebamoff, the third-generation restaurateur, brings a deep passion for both the steakhouse and the broader community to the table. His father, Tom, and grandfather, Steve Gouloff, had established a strong foundation in the restaurant industry, ensuring that the new direction of Auburn City Steakhouse aligns with the values and traditions of the area.
Today, Auburn City Steakhouse offers a diverse dining experience, accommodating a range of guests from casual diners to special occasion hosts. The main dining room on the first floor provides a spacious setting for family gatherings and romantic dinners, while the Davis & James Lounge caters to adults aged 21 and above, offering a more intimate and sophisticated atmosphere. For larger events, the private banquet rooms, including The Executive Room and The Grand Room, are available for rent, equipped with modern amenities and designed to meet the needs of corporate and social gatherings. The steakhouse's commitment to using original hardware fixtures not only enhances the aesthetic appeal but also creates a unique and memorable dining experience that resonates with both locals and visitors alike.
Category Tags
What Customers Say
772
Official Google Reviews
Customers of Auburn City Steakhouse have shared consistently positive experiences, highlighting the high quality of their steaks, attentive service, and welcoming atmosphere. Many reviews emphasize the exceptional taste and tenderness of the steaks, particularly the prime rib and ribeye, which are frequently praised as standout dishes. The restaurant's commitment to using fresh, high-quality ingredients is a recurring theme, with customers noting the superior flavor and texture compared to less reputable establishments. Service is another highlight, with staff members described as friendly, knowledgeable, and often exceeding expectations in terms of attentiveness and personalization.
While some reviews mention minor issues such as wait times, burnt steaks, or burnt appetizers, these are relatively rare and often context-specific rather than systemic problems. The restaurant's ambiance, combining elements of historic charm with modern design, is frequently cited as a positive aspect that enhances the dining experience. Additionally, the staff's responsiveness to special requests and dietary needs, such as accommodating keto diets, adds to the overall positive feedback.
The restaurant's pricing is generally viewed favorably, with many customers finding the quality of food and service to justify the higher price points. The availability of special menus and unique offerings, like the Caramel Apple Martini, adds to the appeal for those seeking a distinctive dining experience. Overall, Auburn City Steakhouse consistently receives high ratings and strong recommendations, indicating a loyal customer base that appreciates its culinary excellence and service quality.